One of America’s Rarest Coin Errors – Only 2 Confirmed Specimens Exist
While millions of 1944 wheat pennies were struck in copper, a handful of accidental steel versions escaped the Philadelphia Mint, creating one of numismatics’ most sought-after errors. Here’s how to identify this legendary rarity worth up to $400,000.
Historical Background: The Wartime Coinage Mistake
Why Steel Pennies in 1944?
- 1943 Only: The U.S. Mint officially produced steel cents only in 1943 to conserve copper for WWII
- Accidental Carryover: A few steel planchets (blanks) remained in presses and were struck with 1944 dies
- Survival Rate: Just 2 authenticated examples (PCGS MS-66 & NGC MS-64)
Current Known Specimens:
- PCGS MS-66: Last sold privately for ~$400,000
- NGC MS-64: Displayed at the Smithsonian
Identification Guide: How to Spot This Rarity
Key Diagnostic Features
| Characteristic | 1944 Steel Penny | Regular 1944 Penny |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Zinc-coated steel | 95% copper |
| Weight | 2.70g | 3.11g |
| Magnetism | Strongly magnetic | Non-magnetic |
| Color | Silvery-gray | Reddish-brown |
| Sound | High-pitched “ping” | Dull “clink” |
Step-by-Step Verification
- Magnet Test: Must stick firmly (zinc-plated steel core)
- Weight Check: Precisely 2.70g (±0.05g tolerance)
- Edge Inspection: Should show zinc coating (no copper visible)
- Surface Analysis: Look for original mint luster (no corrosion)
Grading & Value Spectrum
| Grade | Description | Value Range |
|---|---|---|
| MS-65+ | Full original luster | 300,000−300,000−400,000 |
| AU-55 | Light circulation wear | 100,000−100,000−175,000 |
| XF-40 | Moderate wear | 50,000−50,000−85,000 |
Note: All values assume PCGS/NGC certification
Where to Search for This Rarity
Top Discovery Sites
- Original 1940s Coin Rolls (especially Philadelphia mint)
- Estate Collections (look for old wheat penny albums)
- Bank Vault Holdings (some still contain unsearched rolls)
Red Flags of Fakes
❌ Copper-plated steel (real ones have zinc coating)
❌ Wrong weight (must be 2.70g exactly)
❌ Tool marks near date (signs of alteration)
If You Find a Potential Specimen
Critical First Steps:
- Don’t Clean! (Even fingerprints affect value)
- Handle by Edges Only (Use cotton gloves)
- Document Everything (Take timestamped photos)
Professional Authentication:
- PCGS/NGC Submission: $150+ (required for marketability)
- XRF Testing: Verifies steel composition
- Provenance Research: Essential for high-value coins
Free Expert Evaluation
Think you’ve found a 1944 steel cent? Email clear photos to:
📧 steelpenny@pennyverse.info
Subject: “1944 STEEL CENT”
We’ll provide:
✔ Free preliminary assessment
✔ Current market analysis
✔ Next-step recommendations
Leave a Reply