Best Places to Sell Rare Coins in the U.S

At Pennyverse.info, we’ve helped thousands of collectors sell their coins for maximum value. Here are the top 5 best places to sell your rare coins in the U.S., with step-by-step instructions for each method.

1. Heritage Auctions (Best for Coins Worth $1,000+)

Why Choose Heritage:

• World’s largest numismatic auction house
• Record prices for rare coins
• 1.5+ million registered bidders

Selling Process:

1. Submit photos/details through their website
2. Get free appraisal from their experts
3. Choose auction (Weekly, Monthly, or Platinum Night)
4. Ship insured (they arrange secure transport)
5. Receive payment (within 35 days of sale)

💰 Fees: 15-20% buyer’s premium + seller’s fee
⏳ Timeframe: 2-4 months
🌐 Visit Heritage Auctions

---

2. GreatCollections (Best for Certified Coins)

Why Choose GreatCollections:

• Specializes in certified coins (PCGS/NGC)
• Lower fees than Heritage
• Weekly online auctions

Selling Process:

1. Create free account
2. Submit certification numbers for instant quotes
3. Mail coins (insured shipping label provided)
4. Coin appears in next available auction
5. Get paid via check/wire within 14 days

💰 Fees: 10-15% total
⏳ Timeframe: 4-6 weeks
🌐 Visit GreatCollections

---

3. eBay (Best for Coins Under $5,000)

Why Choose eBay:

• Huge buyer audience
• Good for raw/uncertified coins
• Set your own price

Selling Process:

1. Take high-quality photos (front/back/edge)
2. Write detailed listing (include weight, diameter, errors)
3. Choose auction/fixed price
4. Ship insured with tracking
5. Funds released after delivery

💰 Fees: 12.9% + $0.30 per listing
⏳ Timeframe: 1-3 weeks
⚠ Tip: Only sell to buyers with 10+ positive feedback

---

4. Local Coin Shops (Best for Quick Cash)

How to Find Reputable Dealers:

1. Check PCGS Authorized Dealer list
2. Read Google/Yelp reviews
3. Verify ANA member status

Selling Process:

1. Call ahead to schedule appraisal
2. Bring coin in protective holder
3. Get offer (typically 60-80% of retail)
4. Negotiate using recent auction comps
5. Walk out with cash

💰 Fees: None (but lower offers)
⏳ Timeframe: Immediate

---

5. Coin Shows (Best for Rare Errors/Varieties)

Upcoming Major Shows:

• FUN Show (January, Florida)
• ANA World’s Fair of Money (August, varies)
• Long Beach Expo (February/June/September)

Selling Process:

1. Register as seller (50−50−200 table fee)
2. Display coins with clear pricing
3. Network with dealers (best offers often come Sunday)
4. Accept cash/cashier’s check only

💰 Fees: Table cost + travel expenses
⏳ Timeframe: 1-3 days

---

Bonus: Private Collectors (Highest Payout)

How to Find Buyers:

• PCGS CoinFacts population reports
• NGC Registry Set competitions
• Coin forum PMs (CoinTalk, Reddit r/Coins)

Selling Tips:

1. Get coin certified first
2. Use Escrow.com for transactions >$5,000
3. Meet in bank for high-value sales

---

Selling Pro Tips

1. Always get multiple offers
2. Certify coins worth $500+ (PCGS/NGC)
3. Never clean coins (destroys value)
4. Insure shipments (USPS Registered Mail recommended)
5. Keep records for tax purposes

Need help valuing your coin? Get free appraisal from our experts

---