By PennyVerse.info
A single 2000-P Sacagawea dollar just sold for $4,325 – and you might have one in your spare change right now! At PennyVerse.info, we’ve helped collectors identify these rare coins, whether they’re in original packaging or loose. Here’s exactly how to spot this valuable variety.
The $4,325 Cheerios Dollar: Key Facts
✅ Year: Must be 2000-P (Philadelphia mint)
✅ Reverse Feature: Detailed eagle tail feathers
✅ Mintage: Estimated 5,000-10,000 produced
✅ Recent Sales:
- $4,325 (original packaging, 2023)
- $2,100 (unpackaged MS-65, 2023)
- $1,800 (unpackaged AU-58, 2022)
Step-by-Step Identification Guide
1. Check the Basics
- Date: Only 2000 qualifies
- Mint Mark: Must have “P” (Philadelphia)
- Composition: Manganese-brass (gold color)
2. Examine the Eagle’s Tail Feathers
🔍 Cheerios Version:
- Distinct, separated feather lines
- Clear definition between feathers
- Sharper details overall
🔍 Regular Version:
- Blob-like merged feathers
- Weak or missing detail lines
- Softer appearance
3. Verify Weight & Edge
- Weight: 8.1 grams (normal)
- Edge Lettering: “IN GOD WE TRUST” present
- No alterations or added marks

Where These $4,000 Coins Are Found Today
- Original Cheerios Boxes (extremely rare)
- Bank Rolls (mixed with regular dollars)
- Coin Star Reject Bins (often overlooked)
- Estate Sales (in old collections)
Grading & Value Chart
Condition | Packaging | Value Range |
---|---|---|
MS-65+ | Original cereal box | 4,000−4,000−6,000 |
MS-63 to MS-65 | Loose | 1,800−1,800−3,000 |
AU-50 to MS-62 | Loose | 800−800−1,500 |
Circulated | Loose | 300−300−700 |
Selling Your Cheerios Dollar
Best Places to Sell
- Heritage Auctions (for high-grade examples)
- eBay (list as “2000-P Cheerios Dollar”)
- Specialized Dollar Coin Groups (Facebook/forums)
Pro Tips:
- Never clean the coin
- Use natural light for photos
- Mention “detailed tail feathers” in listing
Beware of Fakes
❌ Altered Regular Dollars (feathers artificially enhanced)
❌ Wrong Year/Mint Mark (only 2000-P counts)
❌ “Special Edition” Scams (must be genuine Cheerios issue)
Always verify with PCGS/NGC certification for top value!
Free Resources from PennyVerse.info
Think you’ve found one? Get a free expert evaluation at PennyVerse.info.
Leave a Reply