๐ฐ Decoding “Burning Branches” and “Strikethroughs”: What Makes an Error Truly Valuable? ๐ฐ
At PennyVerse.info, we’re diving into a recent buzz around a “new 2022 dime error” that’s been circulating online. You might see claims that such a dime recently sold for “$13.50” and that you should “watch out for them” in circulation. While it’s always exciting to find something unusual, let’s learn how to evaluate if a “new error” is genuinely valuable or just a minor curiosity, using the 2022 dime as our example.
๐ Key Identification Features (What to Look For on a 2022 Dime)
The image shows a standard 2022 Roosevelt Dime, which looks just like other dimes.
โก๏ธ Obverse (Front – Roosevelt’s Head):
- Franklin D. Roosevelt: The familiar profile of FDR.
- Date “2022”: Visible at the bottom.
- Mint Mark: Look for a “P” (Philadelphia) or “D” (Denver) above the date, as seen on the smaller dime images.
โก๏ธ Reverse (Back – Torch, Olive, and Oak Branches):
- Torch, Olive Branch, Oak Branch: These symbols represent Liberty, Peace, and Strength/Independence.
- “E PLURIBUS UNUM” and “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” / “ONE DIME”: Standard inscriptions.
The “Burning Branch” or “Strikethrough” Error:
The claim states that the error is a “strikethrough on the branch,” sometimes called a “burning branch error.”
- What is a “Strikethrough”? This type of error occurs when foreign material (like grease, cloth, or metal filings) gets on the coin die or planchet before the coin is struck. When the coin is pressed, that material prevents part of the design from being fully impressed, leaving a blank or weakly struck area.
- How to Check: You would need to examine the reverse (back) of 2022 dimes, specifically the branches (the olive branch on the left, the oak branch on the right), to see if there’s any area where the detail is missing, incomplete, or looks “gouged.”
๐ฐ Valuation Breakdown: Separating Hype from Reality ($13.50 for a Dime?)
You might hear that this “new error” sold for “$13.50.” While that’s more than 10 cents, let’s put it into perspective for a coin error:
- Understanding Error Coin Values:
- Major Errors: These are fundamental mistakes in the minting process (e.g., doubled dies like the 1969-S cent, off-center strikes, wrong planchet errors like the 1943 copper penny, mule errors where incorrect dies are paired). These are genuinely rare and can command hundreds, thousands, or even millions of dollars.
- Minor Errors/Varieties: These include things like small die chips, minor die cracks, filled dies (due to grease strikethroughs), or machine doubling (which isn’t a true error). These are relatively common and typically command only a very small premium over face value, sometimes just a few dollars, if any at all.
- The “Burning Branch” Value: A $13.50 sale for a strikethrough error, while higher than face value, is not considered a high value in the world of significant error coins. It’s typical for a minor, interesting anomaly that a specialized collector might pay a small premium for. It’s often driven by novelty or current social media interest rather than extreme rarity or dramatic visual impact.
- The “Hype Factor”: Social media often magnifies the excitement around “new finds,” sometimes leading to initial small sales that get over-emphasized. Always ask: “Is this a truly unique, dramatic error, or a common mint anomaly?”
๐ฌ 5-Step Authentication Protocol: When (and How) to Verify Claims!
For minor errors like strikethroughs, sending them for professional grading (PCGS/NGC) is often not cost-effective, as the grading fee would exceed the coin’s value. However, the principles of authentication still apply for understanding:
- Visual Confirmation: Does the error match descriptions and photos of known examples? Is it a genuine strikethrough, or just wear/damage?
- Understand Error Types: Learn to distinguish between significant minting errors (like doubled dies) and minor anomalies (like strikethroughs or die chips).
- Research Known Varieties: Check reputable error coin websites and forums to see if this “new” error is already well-documented and what typical sales prices are.
- Market Realism: Compare the advertised selling price ($13.50) to truly significant errors (like the 1969-S Doubled Die Lincoln Cent, which sold for over $100,000 for top grades). This helps gauge true rarity vs. minor novelty.
- Seek Expert Opinion (for high value only): For minor errors, online forums for error collectors can offer opinions. For potentially significant errors, always consult PCGS or NGC.
๐ Why Some Errors are Valuable (and Others Are Not!)
โ๏ธ Rarity: How many exist? Is it a few dozen, or thousands? โ๏ธ Visibility/Impact: Is the error dramatic and easily seen, or does it require magnification? โ๏ธ Type of Error: Was it a fundamental mistake in die creation (like a doubled die) or a temporary issue during striking (like a grease filled die)? Generally, die errors are more valuable. โ๏ธ Demand: Does the error excite a broad base of collectors, or just a niche few?
๐ฆ Selling Options (for Minor Errors like This)
- Online Marketplaces: Minor errors like this might be sold to interested collectors on platforms like eBay.
- Small Local Coin Shows: A collector looking for minor varieties might purchase it.
- Don’t Expect Auction House Sales: Major auction houses or professional coin dealers typically only deal with errors that have values in the hundreds or thousands of dollars (or more).
โ ๏ธ Critical Alert: Never attempt to clean, polish, or modify any coin! This can destroy its original surface and any potential value.
๐ธ Immediate Action Required (If You Find a “New” Error!)
If you find a 2022 dime with this type of “strikethrough” error:
- Email us with clear macro photos (front and back, especially the affected area).
- 360-degree video if possible.
- Provide any details about where/when you found it.
๐ Free With Evaluation:
- Our “Minor Error Coin Assessment”
- Guidance on whether professional grading is worthwhile.
๐ฌ “Every anomaly is a lesson, but only true rarities are fortunes. Learning the difference is key to being a smart collector.” – Dr. Eleanor Vance (Chief Numismatist, RareCoin Guild)
[๐ PennyVerse Verification Shield] [๐ Valuation Estimates are subject to market fluctuations. Always verify claims with current market data and professional authentication for major finds.] โณ The lesson learned today: Not every “new error” or coin with a small premium is a “hidden fortune.” Critical thinking, understanding error types, and checking real market values are your best tools in the world of coin collecting!
Reply “2022-DIME” for immediate VIP evaluation! ๐ Visit PennyVerse.info/Coin-Truths for more verification case studies and lessons in numismatic authenticity.
Leave a Reply