🔍 Coin Identification & Historical Significance
What You’re Holding
- Last of Its Kind: Final year of the Indian Head design (1859-1909)
- Historic Transition: Minted alongside the first Lincoln cents
- Mint Mark: Tiny “S” below wreath = San Francisco origin
Why Collectors Obsess Over It
✅ Lowest mintage of all Indian Head pennies (309,000)
✅ Key date – The series’ rarest coin by far
✅ Perfect storm of historical significance + extreme scarcity
💎 Current Market Value (2024 Prices)
| Condition | Value Range | Auction Record |
|---|---|---|
| Good (G-4) | $300 – $450 | – |
| Fine (F-12) | $450 – $650 | – |
| Extremely Fine (XF) | $700 – $1,200 | – |
| Uncirculated (MS) | $1,500 – $5,000+ | $51,750 (MS67) |
Note: Values spike for coins with original red luster (RD designation).
⚠️ 3-Step Authenticity Check
(Counterfeits are rampant – verify before selling!)
1. Mint Mark Inspection
- Genuine: Crisp “S” with proper spacing below wreath
- Fake: Blurry, oversized, or misplaced mint mark
2. Detail Analysis
- Real Coin: Sharp feathers in headdress, clear wreath leaves
- Warning Sign: Flat details or “mushy” lettering
3. Wear Consistency
- Authentic: Even wear on Liberty’s cheek AND wreath
- Red Flag: One side more worn than the other
Pro Tip: Use a 10x loupe and compare to PCGS photo archives.
📈 Where to Sell for Maximum Profit
For Graded Coins (PCGS/NGC):
- Heritage Auctions (Best for MS65+ examples)
- Stack’s Bowers (Ideal for rare copper coins)
- GreatCollections (Strong prices for XF-AU grades)
For Raw/Unverified Coins:
- Get it graded ($30-$50 service via PCGS/NGC)
- Avoid eBay (Too many lowball offers)
- Coin dealer networks (Like PNG members)
🚨 Immediate Next Steps If You Own One
- Handle by edges only – Fingerprints can lower value
- Take macro photos – Date, mint mark, both sides
- Get free appraisal from:
- 📞 PCGS: 1-800-447-8848
- 📧 NGC: service@ngccoin.com
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Could this be in my grandfather’s coin jar?
A: Yes! Many survived in collections – check all 1909 pennies.
Q: How much does grading cost?
A: $50-$150 (worth it for potential 5-figure returns).
Q: Are cleaned coins valuable?
A: Yes, but worth 30-50% less – never clean it yourself!
🔥 Key Takeaways
✔️ Rarest Indian Head cent – Fewer exist than 1916-D dimes
✔️ “S” mint mark is critical – Philadelphia issues are common
✔️ Grading pays off – MS65 can be worth 100x a G-4 coin
Free Verification: Email photos to experts@pcgs.com with subject “1909-S CHECK”.
Leave a Reply