Understanding This Premium San Francisco Mint Rarity
This recently sold 1942-S Lincoln Wheat Cent graded NGC MS67+ RD represents one of the finest known examples of this San Francisco issue, commanding $335 despite being a common-date penny. Here’s why collectors pay premium prices for such coins and how to evaluate your own wheat pennies.
1. Value Breakdown: Why This Coin Sold for $335
Key Value Factors
- NGC MS67+ RD Grade: Top 1% of surviving specimens
- Population Rarity: Only 31 coins graded MS67+ by NGC (with 5 finer)
- Color Quality: Full original red luster (RD designation)
- Eye Appeal: Exceptional surfaces for a wartime issue
Market Comparison
| Grade | Price Range | Population (NGC) |
|---|---|---|
| MS67+ RD | 300−300−400 | 31 |
| MS67 RD | 175−175−250 | 112 |
| MS66 RD | 75−75−125 | 450+ |
| MS65 RD | 30−30−50 | 1,200+ |
2. Authentication & Grading Insights
Critical Grading Criteria
- Surface Preservation: No visible marks at 5x magnification
- Strike Quality: Full detail on wheat ears and Lincoln’s portrait
- Color Retention: 95%+ original red copper color
- Luster: Vibrant cartwheel effect
Red Flags to Spot
❌ Brown toning (downgrades to RB/BN)
❌ Hairlines or cleaning marks
❌ Weak strike on LIBERTY or date
3. Historical Context & Collector Demand
Why 1942-S Commands Premiums
- Final Pre-War S-Mint Cent: Last year before steel penny production
- Lower Mintage: 85 million (vs. 657M Philadelphia coins)
- Condition Rarity: Few survived in gem grades due to wartime circulation
Investment Potential
- 5-Year Trend: 12% annual appreciation for MS67+ examples
- Registry Set Demand: Competitive collectors seeking top-quality coins
4. Where to Find High-Grade Examples
Best Hunting Methods
- Original Mint Sets: Some still exist in old collections
- Bank Roll Searching: Rare but possible finds
- Estate Sales: Look for albums assembled in 1940s-1950s
Recent Discovery
A collector found a MS66RD in circulation that later upgraded to MS67+ at NGC, selling for $375
5. Smart Selling Strategies
Maximizing Your Coin’s Value
- Professional Imaging: NGC/PCGS TrueView adds 10-15% value
- Auction Timing: List during major coin show seasons
- Certification: Cross to CAC for potential green sticker premium
Selling Venue Comparison
| Platform | Fees | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Heritage | 15% | Registry-quality coins |
| eBay | 12.9% | Certified moderns |
| Coin Shows | 0% | Face-to-face deals |
Free Professional Evaluation
Have a potential high-grade wheat penny? Email clear photos to:
📧 grading@pennyverse.info
Subject: “1942-S WHEAT CENT”
We’ll provide:
✔ Free condition assessment
✔ Population report analysis
✔ Current market comparisons
Leave a Reply